Madison & Union Counties · Home of the Confidence Report™
HVAC Repair, Installation & Maintenance Plain City, OH
Plain City sits right on the line between Madison and Union counties — and My Choice Heating & Air covers both sides of it, with a Confidence Report™ on every visit, no matter which side of Route 161 you’re on.
- We report. You decide.
- 5.0 Google rating*
- License #49878
Residential
HVAC service
Service Hours
Mon–Fri 7AM–5PM
Licensed
Bonded & insured
Ruud Pro Partner
Manufacturer status
Plain City was first laid out in 1818 by Dr. Isaac Bigelow — under the name Westminster, then Pleasant Valley, before settling on Plain City in 1851 to avoid confusion with other Ohio towns of the same name. What makes it unusual is where the county line falls: everything north of Route 161 sits in Union County, and everything south sits in Madison County — two different county governments serving one town. Add a historic downtown around the 1902 Farmers National Bank building and town clock, alongside the newer subdivisions going up as Plain City grows toward Columbus, and you get a genuinely mixed housing stock — from century-old homes near Chillicothe Street to systems installed in the last few years.
That mix means no two service calls in Plain City look the same — exactly the kind of situation the Confidence Report™ was built for: a clear, documented answer regardless of when your system was installed or which county your address falls in.
1818
City Founded
Counties Served
Madison & Union
43064
ZIP Code
20 Mi.
From Home Base
Local Advantage
WHY PLAIN CITY HOMEOWNERS CHOOSE US
One Call, Both Counties
Whether your address falls in Madison County or Union County, it's the same technician, the same pricing, and the same Confidence Report — the county line doesn't change how we treat your home.
Built For A Growing Town
Plain City's housing stock ranges from century-old homes near downtown to brand-new construction on the edges of town — we size and service both correctly.
Documented, Not Just Spoken
Every job ends with a written Confidence Report: what we found, what it means, and what your real options are.
Family-Owned, Neighbor-First
Owner Alex Troyer runs My Choice the way he'd want a technician to treat his own family's home — because a lot of the homes we service belong to people we already know.
Available in Plain City
HVAC SERVICES IN PLAIN CITY
Air Conditioning
Repair, install, replace, maintain, mini-split
Heating
Furnace repair, installation, replace, maintain.
Heat Pumps
Incl. cold-climate & dual fuel
Indoor Air Quality
Filtration, humidifiers, zoning
Maintenance Plans
From $120/yr
Every Plain City Visit Includes a Confidence Report™
Inspect & diagnose → document the findings → translate to plain English → present your options → you decide. Same process whether you're in the Madison County half of town or the Union County half.
Built Around Trust
Licensed, Insured & Guaranteed
Ohio HVAC License #49878
EPA Universal Certified
20-Yr Workmanship
On every installation
10/10 Parts & Labor
Where applicable
Free 2nd Opinions
& free replacement estimates
1-Yr 100% Buy-Back
On qualifying new systems
Accidental Damage Covered
Fixed by a pro of your choosing
Testimonials
Real Customer Reviews
NEARBY TOWNS WE ALSO SERVE
Communities Near Plain City
Just outside Plain City? We’re there just as fast.
Common Questions
PLAIN CITY QUESTIONS, ANSWERED
Do you serve both the Madison County and Union County sides of Plain City?
Yes. The Route 161 county line running through town doesn’t change our service — same technician, same pricing, same Confidence Report on either side.
How fast can you respond to a call in Plain City?
In most cases, same day. Plain City sits along our regular service route between Mechanicsburg and the rest of Central Ohio, so it’s a normal stop, not a special trip.
What HVAC services are available in Plain City?
Air conditioning, heating and furnace service, heat pumps, indoor air quality, and maintenance plans — repair, installation, replacement, and maintenance across all of them.
Do you offer financing for a new furnace or AC in Plain City?
Yes, financing is available through Synchrony for new system installations and replacements, so a needed upgrade doesn’t have to wait on your full budget upfront.
What exactly happens during a maintenance visit?
We verify system operation, check component and motor operating efficiency, check safety, and clean the equipment to factory-fresh condition as best we can — then provide a Confidence Report of the system.
Two Counties, One Call Away
Call, text, or send a request — Plain City is a regular stop for us, whichever side of Route 161 you’re on.